SmallBizGenius Analysis
New Era Cap, known for its wide selection of hats and apparel, faces significant challenges in customer satisfaction. While some customers praise the product quality and unique designs, many report issues with shipping, customer service, and order fulfillment.
Category Breakdown
Scores based on analysis of 264 recent reviews
Shipping & Delivery Issues
2.0/10Numerous customers report problems with shipping, including delays, incorrect addresses, and packages marked as delivered but never received. Many reviewers mention that orders take weeks to arrive, and some never arrive at all, causing significant frustration.
42 reviews mention thisCustomer Service Problems
3.0/10A significant number of reviewers express dissatisfaction with New Era Cap's customer service, citing unresponsiveness, unhelpful representatives, and the lack of a phone number for direct contact. Customers report difficulty resolving issues related to missing items, incorrect orders, and returns.
38 reviews mention thisReturns & Exchanges
4.0/10Several customers complain about the restrictive return policy and difficulties with exchanges, particularly regarding sizing issues. Some reviewers mention being offered only store credit instead of refunds or exchanges for defective items.
18 reviews mention thisProduct Quality
8.0/10Some reviewers praise the quality and design of New Era Cap products, highlighting the authenticity and unique styles available. These customers are generally satisfied with their purchases and find the products to be well-made.
15 reviews mention thisOrder Fulfillment Errors
2.5/10Multiple customers report receiving incorrect items or missing parts of their orders. These errors, combined with poor customer service, lead to significant dissatisfaction.
12 reviews mention thisPros & Cons
What Customers Love
"Almost didn’t try to purchase a hat I really wanted from this website because of all the bad reviews. This was the cutest Formula One hat for a woman (it’s pink) I found anywhere so I took the risk."
"Ordered a fairly expensive cap and was dubious after seeing the trustpilot reviews after I had placed the order but the cap came within the expected delivery time frame and was high quality and authentic."
"The navigation within the website is easy to comprehend. The search bar is defiantly the most helpful when searching exactly what I want and what actually exists in inventory."
Common Complaints
"I will never order anything from this company again. My order was supposed to be delivered by 11/28/25… it is now 12/8/25. And nobody can tell me where the 150 dollars worth of hats is. It’s ridiculous."
"Customer service sucks, no one helps when you’re missing items or give updates on the next steps."
"I wished I would have read reviews before purchasing from this company. I bought a hat for husband for Christmas but I bought the wrong size and so I wanted to exchange it for the correct size (same e..."
"Ordered four hats, they took my money, marked the order fulfilled 15 days later. Received only one hat with a completely different tracking number 20 days later."
"This is ridiculous company. How can there be no phone number for customer support or anything. It's 2025."
Common Questions About New Era Cap
Answers derived from customer review patterns
Is New Era Cap legit and trustworthy?
While New Era Cap is a well-known brand, these reviews suggest caution when ordering online. Many customers report issues with shipping, order fulfillment, and customer service, leading to frustration and dissatisfaction. While some customers receive their orders without problems and are happy with the product quality, the high number of negative experiences indicates a significant risk. Potential buyers should weigh the appeal of New Era Cap's product selection against the potential for a problematic transaction.
Based on 45 reviewsDoes New Era Cap have good customer service?
Based on the reviews, New Era Cap's customer service is a major area of concern. A large number of customers report difficulty reaching customer service representatives and receiving timely or helpful responses. The lack of a phone number for direct contact is a recurring complaint, and many reviewers express frustration with the slow and ineffective email support. These issues suggest that customers should not expect a smooth or efficient resolution process if problems arise with their orders.
Based on 38 reviewsIs New Era Cap worth it for small business?
For small businesses, the value proposition of New Era Cap is questionable. While the brand recognition and product selection may be attractive, the consistently poor customer service and shipping experiences reported by reviewers could create significant challenges. The risk of delayed or incorrect orders, combined with the difficulty of resolving issues, may outweigh the potential benefits. Small businesses may want to consider alternative suppliers with more reliable service and support.
Based on 20 reviewsWhat is New Era Cap's return policy like?
The reviews indicate that New Era Cap's return policy can be problematic. Some customers report difficulties with exchanges, particularly regarding sizing issues. Others mention being offered only store credit instead of refunds or exchanges for defective items. Additionally, the 30-day return window, calculated from the purchase date rather than the delivery date, can be restrictive, especially when shipping delays occur. Customers should carefully review the return policy before making a purchase and be prepared for potential challenges.
Based on 18 reviewsWhy are New Era Cap orders getting canceled?
Some reviewers report having their orders canceled without a clear explanation, often citing vague reasons like "fraudulent order." Customers who experienced cancellations were frustrated by the lack of specific information and the inability to resolve the issue with customer service. This suggests potential problems with New Era Cap's order verification process, which can lead to legitimate orders being canceled and customers being left without recourse.
Based on 6 reviewsLooking for Something Different?
Compare New Era Cap against 522 similar lifestyle & perks options.
View Alternatives